• Unused Proposal I am actively looking for critiques
card+theft
by helvetic brands
Work in progress. Constructive feedback welcome.
Number of views: 210
Date Submitted: Feb. 02 '10
As seen on: http://www.helveticbrands.ch

Feb. 02 '10

helvetic brands said:

How would you improve on this?


Feb. 02 '10

kathariney said:

the saw like object doesn't seems to work for me... it looks like "the credit card got a saw to rob other people". Maybe some description about the project and what you're trying to achieve?


Feb. 02 '10

nido said:

makes perfect sense to me... no suggestions... now to the proverbial...


Feb. 02 '10

absoludicrous said:

CC sitting on the floor, saw coming through, cutting a hole out beneath the CC. I get it.


Feb. 02 '10

epsilon said:

I would lay the card flat on the surface and fix the direction the saw is pointing at. Right now I am seeing an ID/security card on a string with a clip on the other end.


Feb. 02 '10

kathariney said:

totally missed the concept.... maybe instead of having the cut line start right behind the card, have it start the the 2 o'clock position? so it looks like it's almost completing sawing the hole, and the cut line won't looke like a string attached to the card... also maybe the cut line can be finer and the saw seems like can be wider on the bottom, so it doesn't look like a key?


Feb. 02 '10

firebrand said:

makes perfect sense to me too. If anything, the angle of the saw blade doesn't quite match the cut?


Feb. 02 '10

michaelspitz said:

^Exact same comment. Really fun idea! :)


Feb. 02 '10

andreiu said:

perspective..


Feb. 03 '10

fogra said:

I would agree with showing the card laid flat with perspective for both card and saw.


Feb. 03 '10

helvetic brands said:

Thanks to everyone for the great feedback. Unfortunately this direction will no longer be continued as the client and myself feel it may have too much of a negative connotation.


Please login/register to make a comment, registration is easy, signup