-
Client work I am actively looking for critiques
- 365 Design
- by JDMdesigner
- A Branding Company.
- Number of views: 8401
- Date Submitted: Jun. 28 '09
- Added to Gallery: Jun. 30 '09
Jun. 29 '09
alldesign said:Forgive me, but could someone tell me what the lines above 'design' are supposed to say? It's a little unclear. Sorry if that offends...
Jun. 29 '09
NeilMcDonald said:Reminds me of one of those magic eye pictures. You kinda need to diverge the eyes to see it. Contrasting and memorable.
Jun. 30 '09
tokostyler said:i think people need to read 365 but its not very clear and it seems to need a little help:)
Jun. 30 '09
tass said:unfortunately i agree tokostyler, it looks good but i cannot read/imagine it without the additional info
Jun. 30 '09
lundeja said:I found it extraordinarily hard to get the numbers 365 out of that without reading the title. I think there are probably better type choices for "DESIGN" too.
Jun. 30 '09
esotericsean said:Yeah, it took me a long time to realize that it was "365" (had to read comments, too).
My first thought was to look in the "white" space (or in this case "yellow" space), but the actual type is in the black lines. Not what you'd expect.
Looks cool, though :)
Jun. 30 '09
smartinup said:while the 365 doesnt jump off the page at you, i think it is still very well done and i like the couple seconds it takes to see it.
Jun. 30 '09
lefty said:enven knowing the meaning i read HGS. You have a version with fine lines, i think it helps. You should work something in between
Jun. 30 '09
madebyshift said:Great mark, once I realized it was "365." However, I initially saw "HGS."
Perhaps working with the thickness of the marks, you could better portray a "365?"
Jul. 01 '09
macessences said:nice but I made some time ago on the basis of the logo 'beed' - http://www.behance.net/Gallery/Logopack-01/222038
Jul. 01 '09
garavi said:I need to close my eyes to half to see 365 in this mark. But still, I like idea!
Jul. 01 '09
dannygdammit said:yeah.. I have to agree with some that this isn't readable.. not until the 365 was explained to me...
Jul. 01 '09
dbunk said:I feel yellow and black are definitely not the colors if u r targeting Businesses. Maybe a grey instead of black would add some lux to it.
Straight edges instead of rounded edges and reducing the space between the lines might also solve the problem to an extent.
Jul. 01 '09
gjrdesign said:I really take a long time seeing the logo, but just understand what the lines means cause you explain. Visually is nice but funcionally not.
Jul. 01 '09
jakes said:without any explanation I doubt any of us designers would know what it stands for...let's alone the casual reader. Visually it really looks great...but readability comes first.
Jul. 01 '09
jakes said:just curious, have you thought about putting "365 Design" instead of just "Design" on the bottom. That would help reinforce the mark imo.
Jul. 01 '09
bouchardoli said:I agree with jakes. It's cool, but with 365 design under would reinforce your mark.
Jul. 01 '09
teight said:I like it, I did a logo with a similar style (http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/65247) and the client didn't get it, cool idea though, hopefully your client likes yours
Jul. 01 '09
logomotive said:IMO this design does not work. It seems your trying to hard for some cleverness rather than strong and memorable mark which makes a good logo. If you can capture both it's always great. I like logos that you have to take a second look at to figure it our but this does not make it it IMO.
Jul. 01 '09
Siah-Design said:I must agree with Mike. It took me about 30 seconds to figure it out and I showed it to a graphic design buddy of mine and it took him almost 5 minutes. Its a good feeling when you figure it out but I don't think its worth it. Just my two cents...
Jul. 01 '09
logomotive said:Not saying it's bad just questioning if it could be improved, simplified so the average viewer could relate? and if so that would make it more memorable and stronger. Think like a laymen when designing, I admit I've gotten sucked into cleverness myself but have to cater to everyone IMO.
Jul. 01 '09
logomotive said:Why not try 3 horizontal lines, don't know just offering my 2 cents also. Do your own thing though.
Jul. 01 '09
fogra said:I liked Raja's version for the 365 mainly because the 'x' was a surprise:
http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/1337
I do agree with others though that '365 design' needs to be placed beneath the mark.
Jul. 02 '09
zerocommazero said:I know you're going for the bar code look but when i see bar codes, they are solid lines, not broken. I don't know if that look can be achieved here and making the numbers readable goes against the symetrical pattern that a bar code is. Maybe you could try adding sharp corners instead of round ones at important character strokes or put in some thin vertical lines as well to make it look more like a bar code and not be overly distracting. just food for thought.
Jul. 09 '09
Gaard said:Actually I think it's great, I don't have a problem with people needing time to find something. The arrow in Fedex goes unnoticed all the time. Anyway I believe the problem is not so much with clarity of the design but the fact it's on screen. Print this out, then show it to others and see if they can read 365. It should be easier visually since black is more prominent in print being pigment. Whereas here people see the neg space first because it's lighter and on-screen is light based. If this is exclusively for web, well... you may need to re-think the color scheme, or at least invert them.
Jul. 17 '09
evrt studio said:It gives an interesting look, but personally I think if something is not legible or people have to ask what it is, it doesn't work
Please login/register to make a comment, registration is easy, signup
Jun. 29 '09
chirp said:But I love it! This is awesome!