Gallerized
May. '11
6025
Description:
Finally happy. Thanks for your help, everyone.
__
Hand drawn type for a bakery - would really value some fairly urgent feedback on this one please - think it reads ok, but would be very keen to have that verified! Cheers
Status: Work in progress
Commenting: Actively seeking critiques
milou said on May. 18 '11
florisvoorveld said on May. 18 '11
artboy said on May. 18 '11
tfishman said on May. 18 '11
florisvoorveld said on May. 18 '11
justinbakerdesigns said on May. 18 '11
artboy said on May. 18 '11
nathantrafford said on May. 18 '11
Bernd said on May. 18 '11
artboy said on May. 18 '11
Nathan, interesting stuff. I'll have a quick think about making that work. For me I actually really like the loop on the d and l - it gives a good flow and results in what I think is a really nice shape. I don't see an H (although I can see how it could appear as an H) but a couple of people on here mentioned it so I have to weigh it up. Cheers!
And thanks everyone for their feedback so far.
lkwdart said on May. 18 '11
artboy said on May. 18 '11
jurcek said on May. 18 '11
LadyGrey said on May. 18 '11
Looks very nice
action said on May. 18 '11
artboy said on May. 19 '11
artboy said on May. 19 '11
milou said on May. 19 '11
artboy said on May. 19 '11
milou said on May. 19 '11
artboy said on May. 19 '11
action said on May. 20 '11
cpuentes23 said on May. 20 '11
Mikeymike said on May. 20 '11
herbyderby said on May. 20 '11
My thoughts: Make the loop of the L a little taller. And perhaps make the inside of the swirl of first "O" a smidge fatter so it makes it like a dab, or blot of icing.
Again such a fabulous, beautiful piece.
cresk said on May. 20 '11
justinbakerdesigns said on May. 20 '11
bitencourt said on May. 20 '11
brandsimplicity said on May. 20 '11
logomotive said on May. 20 '11
-m- said on May. 20 '11
artboy said on May. 23 '11
Yep, it's a toss up as to wether it's readable or not. I think it is, client thinks it is and enough people have given positive feedback about it - I'm happy enough.
Thanks again everyone that helped out with feedback and left nice comments - much appreciated.
raja said on May. 27 '11
artboy said on Jun. 03 '11
atomicvibe said on Nov. 15 '11
I see that others have brought up some legitimate concerns about readability - specifically relating to the d-l combo. While I agree with the logic behind their concerns, I honestly don't see it as being a problem here. For what it's worth, I read it as "Oodles" right away.
Funny thing about readability. To me, it becomes problematic when a word or words can easily be mistaken for something else. But sometimes, people don't give enough credit to the human brain for being able to instinctively and involuntarily seek to derive logic and meaning, and to quickly decipher puzzles it encounters.
That's how I look at your Oodles logo: a visual puzzle to solve. But, for people who speak idiomatic English, this really shouldn't that difficult of a puzzle - especially since you've obviously put a lot of work into creating a visual onomatopoeia by making an association to the world "noodles."
I assume this to be an American bakery (or at least a bakery in a country that speaks native, idiomatic English), and as a native English speaker myself, my brain sees the fluid, loopy forms, makes the connection to the word "noodles," and by instantaneous process of elimination, I determine that there is absolutely no possibility this word could be anything BUT "Oodles." It certainly isn't "OoHes," and there's no way it's "Oodbes." Why? Because those words don't make any damned sense, that's why. "Oodles" makes sense. In this situation, my brain had to make an educated guess, and thanks to your brilliant visual, it guessed correctly.
So yes, this could be more legible, I suppose, and generally speaking, we designers should always strive for maximum legibility. But sometimes, like in this particular situation, being like 90% legible is enough.
AND I'M OUT!
ocularink said on Nov. 15 '11
artboy said on Jul. 26 '12
If you could let me know who it was that'd be great...!
ClimaxDesigns said on Jul. 26 '12
artboy said on Jul. 30 '12
artboy said on Jul. 30 '12
Please login/register to make a comment, registration is easy, signup