No problem, aren't we all just glad that the "concept theft", "bucks before backbone" logo that was on "BRANDSTACK":http://brandstack.com - was removed, but congrats though on being featured here though.
Oh I get it now, it's all about execution rather than concept and creativity. Well then by all means, bravo! bravo! bravo! By this logic then - I do agree with that this is the best execution, thus far until we see more.
I've removed this logo based on http://www.logolounge.com/logo_details.asp?qstr=ljXnnh this logo which is the closest of the ones you posted.
Obviously, Robert, you have a vested interest in Brandstack, and no one here was blaming or implicating Brandstack in anyway in any of the comments, the issue was simply with a user on your site.
This logo was removed from the gallery the same day you pointed out various similar logos, the fact of the matter is that this site is not set up as a sales site. Yours is, so the responsibility to remove logos of questionable origin would be more paramount on your site.
muse7 said on
Jun. 16 '10
Darling Logo ponders - Don't be so quick to judge. Let me remind you "Say cheese" is the first thing that people say when taking a photograph in the United States. As McGuire Design visually showed you this concept has been used for many photographers, no one owns it. Furthermore, when I was working on flutterpics, http://logopond.com/gallery/detail/82402 Oct. 24 '09 I was also working on this concept. The only reason I didn't put it in my logo pond portfolio is because I was respecting the request of Logo Pond in not posting logos that I plan to sell on brandstack. My concept IS a camera, this one that you want to accuse me of stealing is NOT. It is a dialogue bubble made out of cheese. My camera is a character, complete with eyes, freckles and a smile and yes he is made out of cheese. Oh and most ironic part, webcore only contacted me with threats when they decided they were going to post it on brandstack. This is a sad day indeed.
webcore said on
Jun. 17 '10
@muse7 I usually try to avoid Internet conflict but I fail to see how you have the audacity to make such a claim. This has now evolved into a matter of principle.
You clearly took an existing design of yours (the camera) and hastily formed it into cheese, added a speech bubble, similar brand name and even the same color background to your design. You were essentially trying to sell the same image of yours (the camera) twice on Brandstack (an immorality in itself - which someone else happened to point out in the comments for your logo) in a quick hasty move for a sell a similar concept after viewing the positive feedback for this design on Logopond. We can see this by the fact that the quality of the logo was very poor, whilst the remainder of your work is of a high standard. There is absolutely no doubt in my mind this is the very move you made.
As for "threats" you were sent a polite message as soon as your work was brought to our attention when the work was assumed to be 100% original. As highlighted we are now aware that there happens to be many similar designs created in the past and I'm sure there will be more to come - which won't raise such conflicts. The difference in this case however is your clear lack of moral fiber in the fact that you are now going as far to try and push the suggestion that the work (and comments) herein weren't the clear inspiration for you to make such a hasty move. For that reason alone I concur that it is a very sad day indeed - at least on your part.
Seeing your camera on here Muse7 leads me to believe you didn't actually 'steal' Mikes idea about the hole of the cheese being the lens ect. so my apologies for my part in that accusation, seems like an odd coincidence.
fogra said on Jan. 07 '10
JoePrince said on Jan. 07 '10
LOGOMOTIVE said on Jan. 07 '10
andreiu said on Jan. 07 '10
nickosma said on Jan. 07 '10
brandsimplicity said on Jan. 07 '10
rudy hurtado said on Jan. 07 '10
ethereal said on Jan. 07 '10
Thrasher317 said on Jan. 07 '10
michaelspitz said on Jan. 07 '10
cerise said on Jan. 07 '10
ahab said on Jan. 08 '10
A_O_K said on Jan. 08 '10
logomotive said on Jan. 08 '10
webcore said on Jan. 09 '10
@logomotive I agree. I had the same thought yesterday!
oscarcuriel said on Jan. 12 '10
siah-design said on Jan. 12 '10
Tømme said on Apr. 22 '10
fogra said on May. 15 '10
webcore said on Jun. 13 '10
ClimaxDesigns said on Jun. 13 '10
logomotive said on Jun. 13 '10
lumo said on Jun. 13 '10
lumo said on Jun. 13 '10
pacmanb said on Jun. 13 '10
Mad Skimo said on Jun. 13 '10
ALL4LEO said on Jun. 13 '10
webcore said on Jun. 13 '10
cseven said on Jun. 13 '10
felro said on Jun. 13 '10
dezinart said on Jun. 13 '10
dotflo said on Jun. 13 '10
misterm2010 said on Jun. 14 '10
Can you tell me what typeface (if any) that you used? Would be ideal for a project I am working on. Nothing to do with photography or cheese :)
webcore said on Jun. 14 '10
dianna_carmonna said on Jun. 14 '10
koma said on Jun. 14 '10
radhacelis said on Jun. 14 '10
Mikeymike said on Jun. 14 '10
misterm2010 said on Jun. 14 '10
damaraputra said on Jun. 15 '10
SteveG said on Jun. 15 '10
mcguire design said on Jun. 15 '10
http://www.logolounge.com/logo_details.asp?qstr=ljXnnh
http://www.logolounge.com/logo_details.asp?qstr=ohUd
http://www.logolounge.com/logo_details.asp?qstr=ohUe
http://www.logolounge.com/logo_details.asp?qstr=efRo%60
http://www.logolounge.com/logo_details.asp?qstr=lnVahb
webcore said on Jun. 15 '10
mcguire design said on Jun. 15 '10
webcore said on Jun. 15 '10
mcguire design said on Jun. 15 '10
janzabransky said on Jun. 15 '10
mcguire design said on Jun. 15 '10
mcguire design said on Jun. 15 '10
ClimaxDesigns said on Jun. 15 '10
Obviously, Robert, you have a vested interest in Brandstack, and no one here was blaming or implicating Brandstack in anyway in any of the comments, the issue was simply with a user on your site.
This logo was removed from the gallery the same day you pointed out various similar logos, the fact of the matter is that this site is not set up as a sales site. Yours is, so the responsibility to remove logos of questionable origin would be more paramount on your site.
muse7 said on Jun. 16 '10
webcore said on Jun. 17 '10
You clearly took an existing design of yours (the camera) and hastily formed it into cheese, added a speech bubble, similar brand name and even the same color background to your design. You were essentially trying to sell the same image of yours (the camera) twice on Brandstack (an immorality in itself - which someone else happened to point out in the comments for your logo) in a quick hasty move for a sell a similar concept after viewing the positive feedback for this design on Logopond. We can see this by the fact that the quality of the logo was very poor, whilst the remainder of your work is of a high standard. There is absolutely no doubt in my mind this is the very move you made.
As for "threats" you were sent a polite message as soon as your work was brought to our attention when the work was assumed to be 100% original. As highlighted we are now aware that there happens to be many similar designs created in the past and I'm sure there will be more to come - which won't raise such conflicts. The difference in this case however is your clear lack of moral fiber in the fact that you are now going as far to try and push the suggestion that the work (and comments) herein weren't the clear inspiration for you to make such a hasty move. For that reason alone I concur that it is a very sad day indeed - at least on your part.
nitish.b said on Jun. 17 '10
The idea is to common...IMO
ClimaxDesigns said on Jun. 20 '10
Different Perspective said on Oct. 25 '11
Please login/register to make a comment, registration is easy, signup