I appreciate your comments, guys. When you go for simple, there are going to be similarities. It's the little touches that differentiate it. That, and being used in a different industry.
Nice combination of elements, Jeff. None of the logos mentioned look like this one. Yea, sure there are similarities, but come on!! Reminds me of this, reminds me of that...blah, blah, blah.
Chris (cseven), John, Epsilon - I really appreciate your support guys.
I'm not opposed to people pointing out similarities, unless it's petty. That's one of the reasons I joined LogoPond, so I could get feedback on my work. It's impossible to have a mental catalog of every logo ever designed, so more eyes is a good thing. I do pay attention when someone points out something that is legitimately too close to something I've designed. In the crowded world of logo design, that would mean it would have to be pretty much identical.
I'm holding my ground here on principle. I don't want to send the message that I'm going to cave in every time someone points out a similarity.
Too often people tend to think the internet is a free-for-all and they can say whatever they like. Not so ... slander is slander.
alldesign said on
Jul. 17 '09
I personally believe this logo is different enough that it's not an infringement on the other. Just my two cents. And, as a designer, I always keep in mind that...ultimately, there's really nothing new under the sun. Not that it justifies plagiarism when it actually does happen, but creative minds often think alike, even when it's not intended to happen. Blatant plagiarism is one thing, creative similarities are another. Good work, Quirk.
coy said on
Jul. 17 '09
Quirk-great image. similarities in others.. YAWN.. you've excuted the style superior to any of the others pointed out.
mmsweb needs his head checked and is lucky this site if so friendly, or he'd need a real flame suite. lol..
MomentumMagazine said on Jun. 16 '09
cseven said on Jun. 16 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 17 '09
tasbo said on Jun. 25 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 25 '09
Tømme said on Jun. 26 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 26 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 26 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 26 '09
gustavocadar said on Jun. 26 '09
gustavocadar said on Jun. 26 '09
mmartdesign said on Jun. 26 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 26 '09
apsaracreative said on Jun. 26 '09
http://identityworks.com/also_noted/Mammoth_Mountain_144.gif
http://www.hornallanderson.com/#/project/75/0/
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 26 '09
jennyb said on Jun. 26 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 26 '09
mdlogo85 said on Jun. 26 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 26 '09
moxelcreative said on Jun. 27 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 27 '09
OcularInk said on Jun. 27 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 27 '09
mabu said on Jun. 28 '09
JohnM said on Jun. 28 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 28 '09
marc00 said on Jun. 29 '09
bluegg said on Jun. 29 '09
I guess you've got to work out how many similar logos and how similar they are make it a trademark issue. Nice work never the less.
QuirkDesign said on Jun. 29 '09
marvinslap said on Jul. 01 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jul. 02 '09
n0xi3 said on Jul. 03 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jul. 04 '09
Petro said on Jul. 06 '09
2ccreative said on Jul. 13 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jul. 13 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jul. 17 '09
I'm not opposed to people pointing out similarities, unless it's petty. That's one of the reasons I joined LogoPond, so I could get feedback on my work. It's impossible to have a mental catalog of every logo ever designed, so more eyes is a good thing. I do pay attention when someone points out something that is legitimately too close to something I've designed. In the crowded world of logo design, that would mean it would have to be pretty much identical.
I'm holding my ground here on principle. I don't want to send the message that I'm going to cave in every time someone points out a similarity.
Too often people tend to think the internet is a free-for-all and they can say whatever they like. Not so ... slander is slander.
alldesign said on Jul. 17 '09
coy said on Jul. 17 '09
mmsweb needs his head checked and is lucky this site if so friendly, or he'd need a real flame suite. lol..
QuirkDesign said on Jul. 17 '09
QuirkDesign said on Jul. 17 '09
cseven said on Jul. 17 '09
Please login/register to make a comment, registration is easy, signup