Logopond

Congratulations helvetic brands on being the first user to upload 1000 logos, what a machine!

by • Uploaded:

7519

Status: Nothing set

Commenting: Not seeking critique, comments fine

View Swimmers: 0

More from this user:

sdijock said on Jun. 20 '07

Dude, NICE logo! As a designer from NJ and former soccer player, well done. I only have two minor suggestions. 1.) Take out the black gap between the "R" and the "O" as it's a little distracting and you don't need it. 2.) As cool as the red sunburst bars are in the background they might fill in at smaller sizes - maybe take some out and make them slightly thicker.

kult house said on Jun. 20 '07

The black gap between the R/O doesn't distract me whatsoever, and I disagree with the burst lines. Not every single detail must be completely distinguishable at minute sizes. I think the fine lining gives it a crisp sense of detail and refinement.

My only two suggestions are to work on the outermost gray border and give it a simple highlight bevel as it's a little "rubbery" looking (unless that was your goal? Sorry..bad pun) and I think the steel of the soccer ball could use a light, streaking highlight band across the plates to really hammer in that "metal effect". As it is, the ball looks a little too much like it's in the shade. Since it's indoors, the illusion of a ceiling light striking the steel plates would be a nice touch.

dreamerworx said on Jun. 20 '07

Hmmmmm nice indeed :))) I like that along with the metal ball you added the welding sparks (I think?) like the metal ball bounced off a metal player's foot or something, nice touch :))

sdijock said on Jun. 21 '07

Well kult house, since we're in a disagreeing mood, let me disagree with you. I think the soccer ball is fine as it is. He's trying to convey a soccer ball in an iron mill. Iron mills are dark places, so showing light bouncing off the top of the ball wouldn't make sense. Also, the shading on the ball is lighter at the base where the sparks illuminate it and darker at the top. So adding lighting to the top of the ball would defeat the purpose of the spark light. As for the sunburst lines, I'm not suggesting taking a lot of them out and I'm not suggesting making them really wide. If the intent was to keep the lines legible then my suggestion to robert would be to modify them slightly so it would work at all sizes. When I design logos I strive to design for legibility and to maintain the integrity of the logo in whatever capacity it's used in - which my clients tend to appreciate, as I'm sure robert's would as well. And taking the gap out from between the letters would make the logo cleaner. I'll give you the border comment though.

robertscully said on Jun. 21 '07

tnx for the comments guys.
I appreciate them.

Cheers
-Rob

kult house said on Jun. 21 '07

sdijock, I understand the sparks are illuminating the ball. I wasn't trying to suggest he change the entire lighting of the ball, but to make the front plates get an extra kick of reflective light on them so they aren't quite so plastic looking.

firebrand said on Jun. 21 '07

Great concept and execution Rob.

kaimere said on Jun. 22 '07

well executed

ahab said on Jul. 08 '07

COOL!

firebrand said on Oct. 10 '07

Totally underrated. Great work, Rob.

Please login/register to make a comment, registration is easy, signup

Logopond Book V1 - PreSale Now!

Logopond Book V1 - PreSale Now!